Maddie Brooks has always had high standards for guys. She has yet to find one who can live up to the romantic, classic Hollywood heartthrobs, especially the dreamy song-and-dance man Gene Kelly. When Maddie begins to carpool with Jesse Morales, her new neighbor and star pitcher of the high school baseball team, she's immediately struck by his wit, good looks, and love for his family, but a guy so into sports is definitely not her style. Then Maddie discovers that Jesse was raised a dancer and still practices in the community theater dance studio to keep in shape. Perhaps Maddie's perfect dream guy exists after all. However, when it becomes clear that baseball, not dance, is Jesse's real passion, can Maddie find a way to let her dream guy go and appreciate the charms of the amazing guy right in front of her?