Pinkalicious has lost a tooth, and unfortunately it was her sweet tooth! Without it she is unable to taste anything sweet. Jelly beans taste like pebbles. Candy hearts taste like coal.
But that's not all. Pinkalicious has lost her own sweetness, too. Could the Tooth Fairy send her something sweet to eat, something she could really taste?
When the Tooth Fairy sends Cupid, the Easter Bunny, and even a Christmas elf in her place, Pinkalicious leaves rude notes underneath her pillow. Finally, the Tooth Fairy herself returns with a special message for Pinkalicious about being sweet to others.
This delicious story comes full circle in the end when Pinkalicious finally gets the sweetness she's been seeking and offers some chocolate coins to her brother.