What does it take to stop a miracle? Nineteen-year-old Andi Grant adores her six-year-old brother Daniel, a "miracle child" who survived a fall down a Pennsylvania mine shaft. People regularly come to him for blessings and healings, which often seem to work, but Andi worries about their effects on her brother, especially when she finds signs of a stalker around their home. With the help of her once-and-maybe-future boyfriend Jeff, she comes up with an audacious, dramatic plan to stop the attention on Daniel forever: an "Anti-Miracle" that will unravel with the slightest examination of the facts, and cast doubt on his powers forever after. As her plan comes together, the stalker draws closer, and the clock ticks toward Daniel's star turn at the local Paradise Days celebration, Andi finds herself wrestling with her own beliefs in God and her brother, and wondering if what she really needs is...a miracle.