Create a List

List Name

Rename this List
Save to
Back to the Top Teaching Blog
September 23, 2009

Regarding "Just Right" Books

By Victoria Jasztal

    This photo is of a student writing a journal entry.

    I am ready to be upfront with my audience. One of my biggest woes I have encountered so far this school year has been motivating students to choose "Just Right" books. I have watched many students make tremendous choices with the "five finger test" and by "interviewing" their books (looking at the front cover, back cover, and the contents inside), yet not all students have been making the greatest of choices.


    I have observed students for about a month now to see how they are making progress in this area. One of the boys in my class has done the "right thing" in this respect. A voracious reader of Harry Potter and fantasy books, he discovered the Nightmare Academy series by Dean Lorey. He read the first book, Monster Hunters, in the first few weeks of school and read another book this past week that challenged his thinking. He is now on the second book in Dean Lorey's series and is enjoying it. Another voracious reader who sits near him has read five or six books this year at school and home from a variety of genres from a 4th-6th grade level. She has read more difficult books before and knows that she wants to seek a book from our classroom library that will provide the appropriate challenge. They have written appropriate journal entries at home. On the other hand, I have looked at the three weeks of journal entries all my students have written and have seen where a few have changed books several times, writing basic summaries every time (despite what I have introduced in class). Perhaps that is what they have done in the past- or they have not journaled at all- so it is a great challenge to get them to make the correct choice without my guidance. I hope for my students to not just look at a cover and tell me that they chose the book because of the pictures or they chose Kingdom Keepers- Disney After Dark, for example, simply because they enjoy going to Disney World. It is also difficult to go to the school library, see students make good choices about their books, and never delve into them, returning them the following week. Unread.

    In the midst of stressing about this last night, I located a great article that encouraged me to think positively about this situation - http://www.learnnc.org/lp/pages/658. This article included a wonderful letter I am going to distribute to parents at Open House tomorrow evening as well as a series of questions parents can reflect on with their children after they have read. I have also reflected on writings I have read from Scholastic contributor Franki Sibberson, who through her professional books and weblog entries encouraged me to work hard with my students this year to locate "Just Right" books in our classroom library. However, I wish I had as much patience as her!

    This year has been challenging because I have never implemented the idea of choosing "Just Right" books and journaling about it before. Sometimes one may look at the title of "Scholastic Teacher Advisor" and believe the advisor is somewhat of a sage on all playing fields, yet I am still a rookie in this respect. I am in my sixth year of teaching, and reflecting on the past five years, I was close to where I wanted to be in the second half of last year. However, I advised my students to choose all Newbery award winning books for a particular project and did not focus on choosing "Just Right" books earlier in the year like I should have. Those students were not required to read at home, which I wish I would have required because there is an extensive amount of research connecting independent reading time to achievement.

    Thank goodness I am focusing on improving this just after the first month of school rather than in the seventh or eighth month. To finish, I have a few questions for you-

    • Have you encouraged students to read "Just Right" books in your classroom? Have you experienced similar woes, and how did you work with your students to remedy them? If you conference with your students, how did you approach the conversation?
    • Is there a woe that you currently have where you would like to receive advice?

    I am positive all of us have been in a situation where we have been between "a rock and a hard place". I am also certain that at some point and time we have read extensively about a topic and have felt like we were prepared to implement the new ideas in our classrooms, yet it turned out the implementation was not like we originally intended. It may have turned out to be somewhat of a tedious or daunting task, causing us to "stress out".

    The greatest thing, though, is that we are in a profession where we are encouraged to voice our concerns and receive the greatest help we can from our colleagues to become more effective teachers.

    This photo is of a student writing a journal entry.

    I am ready to be upfront with my audience. One of my biggest woes I have encountered so far this school year has been motivating students to choose "Just Right" books. I have watched many students make tremendous choices with the "five finger test" and by "interviewing" their books (looking at the front cover, back cover, and the contents inside), yet not all students have been making the greatest of choices.


    I have observed students for about a month now to see how they are making progress in this area. One of the boys in my class has done the "right thing" in this respect. A voracious reader of Harry Potter and fantasy books, he discovered the Nightmare Academy series by Dean Lorey. He read the first book, Monster Hunters, in the first few weeks of school and read another book this past week that challenged his thinking. He is now on the second book in Dean Lorey's series and is enjoying it. Another voracious reader who sits near him has read five or six books this year at school and home from a variety of genres from a 4th-6th grade level. She has read more difficult books before and knows that she wants to seek a book from our classroom library that will provide the appropriate challenge. They have written appropriate journal entries at home. On the other hand, I have looked at the three weeks of journal entries all my students have written and have seen where a few have changed books several times, writing basic summaries every time (despite what I have introduced in class). Perhaps that is what they have done in the past- or they have not journaled at all- so it is a great challenge to get them to make the correct choice without my guidance. I hope for my students to not just look at a cover and tell me that they chose the book because of the pictures or they chose Kingdom Keepers- Disney After Dark, for example, simply because they enjoy going to Disney World. It is also difficult to go to the school library, see students make good choices about their books, and never delve into them, returning them the following week. Unread.

    In the midst of stressing about this last night, I located a great article that encouraged me to think positively about this situation - http://www.learnnc.org/lp/pages/658. This article included a wonderful letter I am going to distribute to parents at Open House tomorrow evening as well as a series of questions parents can reflect on with their children after they have read. I have also reflected on writings I have read from Scholastic contributor Franki Sibberson, who through her professional books and weblog entries encouraged me to work hard with my students this year to locate "Just Right" books in our classroom library. However, I wish I had as much patience as her!

    This year has been challenging because I have never implemented the idea of choosing "Just Right" books and journaling about it before. Sometimes one may look at the title of "Scholastic Teacher Advisor" and believe the advisor is somewhat of a sage on all playing fields, yet I am still a rookie in this respect. I am in my sixth year of teaching, and reflecting on the past five years, I was close to where I wanted to be in the second half of last year. However, I advised my students to choose all Newbery award winning books for a particular project and did not focus on choosing "Just Right" books earlier in the year like I should have. Those students were not required to read at home, which I wish I would have required because there is an extensive amount of research connecting independent reading time to achievement.

    Thank goodness I am focusing on improving this just after the first month of school rather than in the seventh or eighth month. To finish, I have a few questions for you-

    • Have you encouraged students to read "Just Right" books in your classroom? Have you experienced similar woes, and how did you work with your students to remedy them? If you conference with your students, how did you approach the conversation?
    • Is there a woe that you currently have where you would like to receive advice?

    I am positive all of us have been in a situation where we have been between "a rock and a hard place". I am also certain that at some point and time we have read extensively about a topic and have felt like we were prepared to implement the new ideas in our classrooms, yet it turned out the implementation was not like we originally intended. It may have turned out to be somewhat of a tedious or daunting task, causing us to "stress out".

    The greatest thing, though, is that we are in a profession where we are encouraged to voice our concerns and receive the greatest help we can from our colleagues to become more effective teachers.

Comments

Share your ideas about this article

Victoria's Most Recent Posts
Blog Post
Saying Farewell as Your Grades 3-5 Advisor

I wanted to take a few moments to take the time to thank you for visiting the Classroom Solutions weblog at Scholastic this past year. Being the grades 3-5 teacher advisor was a "dream come true" for me, as I have loved Scholastic since I indulged in The Baby-Sitters Club series as a child. Posting the weekly topics was an intriguing opportunity. Read more to read about this whirlwind of a year, from the time I found out I was going to be an advisor to the bittersweet departure yesterday.

By Victoria Jasztal
June 11, 2010
Blog Post
1,400 minutes... How do you measure a year?

Yesterday was the day of our end-of-the-year fourth grade awards ceremony, and I was thinking to myself, How do you measure a year? There are challenges we all face, whether they are academic challenges or we must handle difficult situations with our students. Then of course, there are times where we encounter great joy. There are times where we do not feel as if we have planned enough, while on the other hand, there are times in which we plan too much. Then obviously, of course, there are the field trips, and this year, we had our fair share of them, from our local one to the environmental center in Weeki Wachee to the "major ones" such as the Renaissance Festival, Gainesville, and St. Augustine.

Though I have not officially said "Goodbye" to my students as fourth graders, it was still difficult as they watched the 45-minute slideshow, I presented the classroom awards, and I went on stage to present the academic achievement awards such as Superintendent's List (Never below an A for the year), Principal's List ("A" average in all subjects for the year, though B's can be on the report card), and Honor Roll (A's and B's for the year). I felt a phenomenal sense of pride for my students as I presented the eight Superintendent's List awards, the two for Principal's List, and another eight for Honor Roll. My students have achieved a lot, and they should feel a great sense of honor. Read on to hear more about how this special day progressed.

By Victoria Jasztal
June 3, 2010
Blog Post
Reflecting on the School Year

At the end of the school year, most teachers reflect about what their students' have learned and what they can change to improve instruction the next time around. Every year, I sit down for a while and think about what I want to do differently in the coming year.

By Victoria Jasztal
May 27, 2010
Blog Post
Ensuring a Tremendous End to a Memorable School Year

In just three weeks, the 2009-2010 school year will be coming to an end, and prior to then, I plan on doing a few things to ensure it is a memorable time. This week, I invite for you to read about my plans, some of which you can incorporate on your own. Some you will be able to incorporate this year; others you can try for next year!

By Victoria Jasztal
May 19, 2010
Blog Post
Incorporate Math and Science with an Outdoor Camping Day Event

In my parting weeks as your grades 3-5 teacher advisor, I want to advise something important to all teachers: DON’T EVER BE AFRAID TO TAKE RISKS. Last year, I envisioned having a day of camping with my fourth grade students on our school’s nature trail. Today, it became a reality as my students participated in the first outdoor camping event I ever hosted. I am grateful I took the risk. Read on to see the ideas I came up with for this year's event.

By Victoria Jasztal
May 12, 2010
Blog Post
Embrace Creative Technology With These Websites

Do you want to encourage a greater use of technology in your classroom? Whether you want your students to create their own comics, use digital cameras, type information in graphic organizers online, edit photos, or make an online slide show, the links that follow can be particularly useful!

By Victoria Jasztal
May 5, 2010

Susan Cheyney

GRADES: 1-2
About Us