Last week during a reading comprehension lesson, my 2nd graders were arguing with each other . . . and yelling at me!
Really! It’s the truth, but . . . maybe not what you imagined.
It all started when I was about to introduce A Toad for Tuesday, a book that would be the jumping-off point for my winter/animal survival unit. I had handed my class a short passage from it with no introduction or clue about its origin. After a few cold reads on their own and some marking of unfamiliar words, my 7- and 8-year-olds transformed from passive readers to enthusiastic text detectives! Their passion for the task was evident as the discussion started.
"They can't be people, they live under a stump!" vs. "He was washing the dishes! Animals don't do that!"
"It must be December: look at the snow in the 3rd paragraph!" vs. "It snows in January, too!"
My students were participating in a close reading activity when these conversations happened. If you would like to replicate this scene in your own classroom, read on!
"Close reading is a careful and purposeful rereading of a text," according to Dr. Douglas Fisher of the NCTE. It’s an integral part of the Common Core Standards, and the CCS expectation is that by the time a student reaches college age, they will be able to attack complex text and break it down for absolute understanding. By the end of 5th grade, students are to be comprehending literature at the high end of the 4th/5th grade complexity band, which would be around 1000L, independently and proficiently. That kind of skill won’t happen overnight, so . . . we all have a lot of work to do!
It seems students have gotten used to teachers doing some of their work for them. We front-load them with vocabulary lessons, background knowledge, and introductions. That’s good practice as part of the instruction they receive, but our students need to also experience and get accustomed to struggling with rigorous text, independently.
The expectations from the Common Core are that students will learn to attack a passage at the top of their complexity band by 3rd and 5th grades. When I choose text for my 2nd graders for a supported comprehension activity, I choose text that has a Lexile ranking of 600–800L. Measuring the text takes just a few minutes. Use the Lexile Analyzer on the Lexile.com website. Copy and paste the text into Notepad and save it. Then go to the analyzer and browse for your file, and click submit. The Lexile rank and other helpful information appear on the next screen.
Sample 2nd grade text from A Toad for Tuesday
Sample intermediate text from MLK Jr.'s "Letter from Birmingham jail"
Great strategies for teaching close reading
Suggestions for supporting students as they grapple with complex text
It's building confidence in them as readers and in me in knowing that they will be prepared to meet the challenges of the coming years.