Create a List

List Name

Rename this List
Save to
Back to the Top Teaching Blog
March 16, 2017

Rethinking Homework: How Much Is too Much?

By Genia Connell
Grades 1–2, 3–5

    Towards the end of last year, when I was going over directions for that night's homework, one of my students told me, “You give the least homework of any of the third grade teachers.” Other students chimed in that they agreed. I have to admit I was a bit surprised.

    I asked them, “Do you feel like you need more homework?”

    Being third graders, they immediately shouted "NO!" in unison.

    But I began to question myself. I’d cut back on homework over the years. Was I giving enough homework? Was I hampering or hindering their educational growth? I decided the answer, for me, was no. My students weren’t being harmed in any way by bringing less homework home.

    With homework on my mind, I began noticing more and more articles about the pros and cons of assigning work outside of the school day, and I read every one I came across. So now, after all that reading and almost a year having passed, instead of wondering if I’m giving too little homework, I’m wondering if I’m assigning too much.

    I have to believe I’m not the only teacher who finds her or himself in a homework quandary. This week I plan to share how I currently assign homework, my plans for change, and the fears I have of giving less homework. I would love to hear from teachers who have found a way to manage the homework/no homework conundrum.

    My Weekly Homework for Third Graders

    While my district does not have any policies regarding homework, our building generally uses the 10 minutes of homework per grade level guideline. For example, first graders would have 10 minutes of homework, second graders 20 minutes, etc. Even though I aim for 30 minutes of homework a night. I know of course my one-size-fits all homework takes 10 minutes for some and an hour for others.

    Over the past several years I have dropped my homework to three times a week from four. I maintain the same structure each week so it is predictable and busy lives outside of school can be accommodated.

    Each Monday, students receive a version of the homework sheet shown below:

    Students are encouraged to use the sheet as a weekly planner. They can write in when they have karate, soccer practice, religious education, etc.

    Most of the homework, except for math, is handed out on Monday so students can prioritize their work around their schedules. Math homework is directly connected to the day’s lesson and it is handed out on Monday, Tuesday, and Thursday. Wednesday is known as catch-up day when no new homework is handed out. Parents sign the sheet each night and students return it to class each day so I can check it and write notes on it if necessary. Students get stickers to show they have turned in their homework. There is never weekend homework and projects are only done in school.

    Some of the many personal reasons I believe in giving homework include:

    ·      Students learn to manage their time and prioritize responsibilities.

    ·      It gives parents a window into their children’s school work as well as their child’s work/study habits

    ·      It’s working. Parents aren’t complaining about homework. Late homework is a rarity. Our students do well on state assessments and move onto middle school well-prepared.

    What if I Stop Giving Homework?

    Even though part of me says, If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it, I’m seriously considering trying the no homework route for our next marking period. I remember the relief I would feel when my own kids came through the door at the end of the day and announced they had no homework. It’s not lost on me that many of my parents would feel the same way. Family time is precious and too much homework can infringe upon it. My idea for replacing traditional homework would be to ask students to do the following each night:

    ·      Read. Whenever you can, wherever you can.

    ·      Talk to your family about your day. Share what you learned in school.

    ·      Play outside.

    ·      Help out: set the table, unload the dishwasher, make your bed.

    ·      Get to bed early and get a good night’s sleep.

    My biggest fears in going to this alternative homework are:

    ·      Students won’t use the extra time to read, play outside, talk to family members or help out around the house. Instead, they’ll play more video games or YouTube incessantly.

    ·      Parent backlash: Some parents ask for extra homework. I worry how they would react if there was less.

    ·      Students won’t be prepared for the rigors of homework in subsequent grades.

    ·      Assessment scores will fall. Our evaluations are tied to student progress. I’m honestly a bit fearful that an experiment with no homework may impact how well my students do even though some studies find little correlation.

    It’s Decided: I’m Going to Give (Almost) No Homework a Try

    I have to admit I’m fearful of the unknown, but writing this blog post has helped me work through some of my concerns about dropping homework. The school curriculum we follow is rigorous. My third graders have expectations that used to be fourth and fifth grade goals. Our school day doesn’t end until 4:07 p.m. and many students don’t get home until well after that, leaving little downtime, especially if there are other afterschool activities taking place. They just may need more time to be kids.

    Less homework means more time to play with friends and siblings

    I’ll consider the third marking period a “pilot,” knowing I can always make adjustments. There will still be some homework as needed. If classwork isn’t finished because time wasn’t used well in class, that will still be homework. And of course, I’ll still expect my students to read during some of their newfound time.

    I would absolutely love to hear from teachers who have gone from a traditional homework model to no homework. What did you find when you did away with homework? Please share in the comment section below.

    Take care and thanks for reading,

    Genia

    Towards the end of last year, when I was going over directions for that night's homework, one of my students told me, “You give the least homework of any of the third grade teachers.” Other students chimed in that they agreed. I have to admit I was a bit surprised.

    I asked them, “Do you feel like you need more homework?”

    Being third graders, they immediately shouted "NO!" in unison.

    But I began to question myself. I’d cut back on homework over the years. Was I giving enough homework? Was I hampering or hindering their educational growth? I decided the answer, for me, was no. My students weren’t being harmed in any way by bringing less homework home.

    With homework on my mind, I began noticing more and more articles about the pros and cons of assigning work outside of the school day, and I read every one I came across. So now, after all that reading and almost a year having passed, instead of wondering if I’m giving too little homework, I’m wondering if I’m assigning too much.

    I have to believe I’m not the only teacher who finds her or himself in a homework quandary. This week I plan to share how I currently assign homework, my plans for change, and the fears I have of giving less homework. I would love to hear from teachers who have found a way to manage the homework/no homework conundrum.

    My Weekly Homework for Third Graders

    While my district does not have any policies regarding homework, our building generally uses the 10 minutes of homework per grade level guideline. For example, first graders would have 10 minutes of homework, second graders 20 minutes, etc. Even though I aim for 30 minutes of homework a night. I know of course my one-size-fits all homework takes 10 minutes for some and an hour for others.

    Over the past several years I have dropped my homework to three times a week from four. I maintain the same structure each week so it is predictable and busy lives outside of school can be accommodated.

    Each Monday, students receive a version of the homework sheet shown below:

    Students are encouraged to use the sheet as a weekly planner. They can write in when they have karate, soccer practice, religious education, etc.

    Most of the homework, except for math, is handed out on Monday so students can prioritize their work around their schedules. Math homework is directly connected to the day’s lesson and it is handed out on Monday, Tuesday, and Thursday. Wednesday is known as catch-up day when no new homework is handed out. Parents sign the sheet each night and students return it to class each day so I can check it and write notes on it if necessary. Students get stickers to show they have turned in their homework. There is never weekend homework and projects are only done in school.

    Some of the many personal reasons I believe in giving homework include:

    ·      Students learn to manage their time and prioritize responsibilities.

    ·      It gives parents a window into their children’s school work as well as their child’s work/study habits

    ·      It’s working. Parents aren’t complaining about homework. Late homework is a rarity. Our students do well on state assessments and move onto middle school well-prepared.

    What if I Stop Giving Homework?

    Even though part of me says, If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it, I’m seriously considering trying the no homework route for our next marking period. I remember the relief I would feel when my own kids came through the door at the end of the day and announced they had no homework. It’s not lost on me that many of my parents would feel the same way. Family time is precious and too much homework can infringe upon it. My idea for replacing traditional homework would be to ask students to do the following each night:

    ·      Read. Whenever you can, wherever you can.

    ·      Talk to your family about your day. Share what you learned in school.

    ·      Play outside.

    ·      Help out: set the table, unload the dishwasher, make your bed.

    ·      Get to bed early and get a good night’s sleep.

    My biggest fears in going to this alternative homework are:

    ·      Students won’t use the extra time to read, play outside, talk to family members or help out around the house. Instead, they’ll play more video games or YouTube incessantly.

    ·      Parent backlash: Some parents ask for extra homework. I worry how they would react if there was less.

    ·      Students won’t be prepared for the rigors of homework in subsequent grades.

    ·      Assessment scores will fall. Our evaluations are tied to student progress. I’m honestly a bit fearful that an experiment with no homework may impact how well my students do even though some studies find little correlation.

    It’s Decided: I’m Going to Give (Almost) No Homework a Try

    I have to admit I’m fearful of the unknown, but writing this blog post has helped me work through some of my concerns about dropping homework. The school curriculum we follow is rigorous. My third graders have expectations that used to be fourth and fifth grade goals. Our school day doesn’t end until 4:07 p.m. and many students don’t get home until well after that, leaving little downtime, especially if there are other afterschool activities taking place. They just may need more time to be kids.

    Less homework means more time to play with friends and siblings

    I’ll consider the third marking period a “pilot,” knowing I can always make adjustments. There will still be some homework as needed. If classwork isn’t finished because time wasn’t used well in class, that will still be homework. And of course, I’ll still expect my students to read during some of their newfound time.

    I would absolutely love to hear from teachers who have gone from a traditional homework model to no homework. What did you find when you did away with homework? Please share in the comment section below.

    Take care and thanks for reading,

    Genia

Comments

Share your ideas about this article

Genia's Most Recent Posts
Blog Post
Games and Activities to Build Student Vocabulary

Put your reference books to help students power-up their vocabulary with games and activities that make the most of dictionary skills, idioms, antonyms, and synonyms.

By Genia Connell
January 5, 2017
Blog Post
Video Selfies to Improve Fluency

Give your students an assignment to make a 60-second video of themselves reading aloud to show off their fluency skills, and you may discover that they wind up reading for hours in the course of filming their video selfie.

By Genia Connell
December 8, 2016
Blog Post
Chalk Talks to Engage All Students

Chalk Talks are reflective routines that allow all students to simultaneously share their thoughts, ideas, and wonderings in a judgement-free zone. 

By Genia Connell
October 13, 2016

Susan Cheyney

GRADES: 1-2
About Us