You asked about why I choose to use a Reader's Notebook binder instead of a spiral notebook. That is a great question!
After trying out a true notebook approach, I found it was hard for my third graders to keep their ideas and thoughts organized in the notebook as well as their materials. I tried to add tabs to the notebook pages so that the notebook had different sections, but the pages ended up falling out, and students would use random pages to do their reading work. This made the notebooks hard to assess when I collected them to check in on my readers' progress.
I switched to the binder because it is so easy to add new things in a specific order without asking my students to glue in handouts and stick loose papers in their notebooks. My binder has different sections. I like that students can add new reading log pages if necessary, add useful handouts in the mini-lesson handout section, and keep important materials and notes for reading partnership meetings in the partnership section of the binder. They also create genre graphs each month that they add to the genre section. If I did not use a binder, my students would not be able to keep their materials and their reading work organized in a way that is easy for them (and for me) to locate specific materials and information. They also have blank notebook paper at the back of the binder where they respond to their reading like they would in a traditional spiral notebook.
I do happen to have the space in my classroom to store these binders, and I understand your concern about the binders taking up quite a bit of room. However, I do not find them to be cumbersome when students are using them to record their books or respond to their reading. They bring them to the carpet for the mini-lesson each day and have them with them at their book nook at all times during independent reading time.
I hope my ideas have given you some insight about the use of reading binders!
Sign up today for free teaching ideas, lesson plans, online activities, tips for your classroom, and much more.
Choose your grade range:
See a sample >