Administrator Magazine
Scholastic Administrator is a must-read resource for 240,000 of today's results-driven school leaders. Every issue features leadership for education executives, insight and analysis into what's next in education, and reporting on cutting-edge technologies in real life applications.

The Ratings Game

Teaching isn’t baseball—and it’s time we stopped obsessing about teachers' stats.

During the past couple of years, the fascination with measuring and rating teachers' impact on student achievement has gotten completely out of hand. It's as if education has been taken over by a group of fantasy baseball fanatics who have memorized Moneyball but failed to grasp that statistical analysis of players didn't really change the actual game. Statistical analysis of teaching has morphed from a promising area of research into an unhealthy obsession.

How did this happen? First, the data-obsessed school reform community plucked the idea of rating teachers from obscurity and began pushing it as something new. Then the reform-friendly Obama administration made it a disproportionately prominent part of its $4 billion Race to the Top grant competition, beating states and districts and teachers unions over the head with the notion that removing the "firewall" between student data and teacher performance would somehow save education.  

Now, I'm no anti-testing, anti-accountability ideologue. Much to the disappointment of many classroom teachers and school administrators, I've made my peace with standardized testing. I'm one of the few people on the planet (besides some civil rights and disabilities groups) who still defend NCLB's much-loathed AYP school rating system. And I'm just as critical as anyone of the current system most districts use for hiring, paying, and evaluating teachers. That's a sorry mess that needs to be sorted out. But treating value-added ratings of teachers as the be-all and end-all for making schools better seems wasteful and unwise.

Measuring a teacher's impact is just a small part of the teacher quality issue, and the quality issue is just a small part of the overall education puzzle.

Pushing university-based education schools to do a better job of preparing teachers deserves much more energy from lawmakers. Fifteen years ago, education schools fought off proposals to make them accountable for the quality of the teachers they provide to school districts. Since then, report after report has suggested that teacher preparation remains inadequate. And yet, only D.C. and four Race states-Maryland, Massachusetts, New York, and Rhode Island-have indicated that they will make any real use of the ed-school performance data that they are being paid to post online. States that didn't win Race funding have little incentive, rhetorical or financial, to take action.

Teacher quality isn't the sole issue that warrants serious attention, either. Improving the quality and accessibility of early childhood education is one example. Five years ago there was widespread momentum toward making preschool universal. Only in the most recent (and much smaller) round of Race to the Top has there been any meaningful attention to early childhood issues.

Encouraging schools to provide preventative wraparound social services is another issue that should be on the front burner. For all the attention given to Geoffrey Canada's Harlem Children's Zone, wraparound services have remained a second- or even third-tier priority.

In the meantime, the 12 states that won grants (and many others that didn't) are spending inordinately large amounts of time, money, and political capital bringing teacher-rating systems into reality. They may or may not succeed. Either way, most schools likely won't be affected dramatically.

Inevitably, the data hounds and technocrats will continue with their statistical schemes. Already, law enforcement agencies, which led the race into data-based decision-making, boast that they can predict where crimes will occur and even who is likely to be a victim or perpetrator. Soon, statisticians will go from claiming they can measure teachers' impact on learning to claiming they can predict it. Or at least that's my prediction.

  • Teacher Store
  • The Teacher Store  
    Classroom Discussions in Math: A Teachers Guide for Using Talk Moves to Support the Common Core and More

    Classroom Discussions in Math: A Teachers Guide for Using Talk Moves to Support the Common Core and More

    Classroom Discussions in Math: A Teacherís Guide for Using Talk Moves to Support the Common Core and More offers an award-winning, unparalleled look at the significant role that classroom discussions can play in teaching mathematics and deepening students' mathematical understanding and learning. Based on a four-year research project funded by the U.S. Department of Education, this resource is divided into three sections:
    •Section I: Getting Started: Mathematics Learning with Classroom Discussions
    •Section II: The Mathematics: What Do We Talk About?
    •Section III: Implementing Classroom Discussions

    This multimedia third edition continues to emphasize the talk moves and tools that teachers can use to facilitate whole-class discussions that deepen studentsí mathematical understanding.

    Professional Book | Grades K-8
    Add To Cart
    Educators Only
    Classroom Discussions in Math: A Teachers Guide for Using Talk Moves to Support the Common Core and More
    Grades K-8 $71.95
    Add To Cart
  • Teacher Store
  • The Teacher Store  
    The Essential Spanish Phrase Book for Teachers

    The Essential Spanish Phrase Book for Teachers

    by Luisa Perez-Sotelo;Eileen Hogan

    View Sample Pages

    Overcome the language barrier with your Spanish-speaking students and their families with this handy guide and its indispensable tools: English-Spanish translation charts, idiomatic expressions, cognates (words in both languages that are very similar in spelling and pronunciation), and vocabulary pertinent to diverse topics that often occur in a school situation. This slender book, tabbed for quick access, is organized around three sections — Inside the Classroom, Inside the School, and Inside Family Communication — and covers the typical situations and events in an elementary school day. 64 pages.

    Click here to learn more about Scholastic Professional

    You will need Adobe Acrobat Reader® software, version 4.0 or higher, to view and print the sample page above. Get Adobe Reader® for FREE.

    $10.49 You save: 25%
    Professional Book | Grades K-6
    Add To Cart
    Educators Only
    The Essential Spanish Phrase Book for Teachers
    Grades K-6 $10.49
    Add To Cart
Help | Privacy Policy




(Separate multiple email addresses with commas)

Check this box to send yourself a copy of the email.


Scholastic respects your privacy. We do not retain or distribute lists of email addresses.