Scholastic News Online

Scholastic News Online is a free resource with breaking news and highlights from the print magazine.

Available for grades 1-6, Scholastic News magazine brings high-interest current events and nonfiction to millions of classrooms each week.

Additionally, our subscribers have FREE access to Scholastic News Interactive, an exclusive online learning tool featuring digital editions, videos, interactive features, differentiated articles, and much more.

plastic bag blows in the wind Plastic bag blows in the wind. (

Bag-Ban Debate

Communities consider banning plastic bags or charging for them

By Jennifer Dignan | April 14 , 2009

Helping your mom unload groceries from the car, you look down at the plastic bags in your hands. Chances are, it's not the bags that interest you—it's what's inside them.

But you might want to give those bags some thought after all.

Plastic bags are harmful to the environment, and cities and states across the United States are considering placing fees on them or banning them.

One U.S. city, San Francisco, already bans plastic bags in grocery stores. Los Angeles's ban on plastic bags will go into effect in 2010.

New York City, Portland, Oregon, and Seattle, Washington, are also considering bans or fees on plastic bags. So are the states of Colorado, Hawaii, and Maine.

Problems with Plastic

"The average American family takes home almost 1,500 plastic shopping bags a year," says Eric A. Goldstein of the National Resources Defense Council, an environmental group. The total number of plastic bags used in the United States per year is between 70 billion and 100 billion.

Plastic bags are made from petroleum products. It takes about 12 million barrels of oil to make the plastic bags used in the U.S. each year.

Shipping the bags to stores across the country contributes to greenhouse gas emissions.

Most plastic bags eventually end up in a landfill, where they can remain for as long as 1,000 years. But first, or instead, many plastic bags become litter.

As Goldstein puts it, "They're hanging from trees, and littering our beaches." Plastic bags are a major source of ocean pollution as well.

Plastic bags are recyclable, but only about 5 percent of them are recycled. To encourage more recycling, some cities and states are passing laws requiring stores to provide recycling bins for plastic bags.

Bad Ban?

Not everyone supports plastic-bag bans or fees. Some argue those measures place an unfair burden on shoppers. Others say that banning plastic bags or charging for them creates hassles for store owners.

Another major argument against banning or charging for plastic bags is that doing so would increase the use of paper bags. In some ways, paper bags are as bad or worse a threat to the environment than plastic bags.

Unlike plastic bags, paper bags are biodegradable. However, in order to biodegrade, they must be exposed to air—which does not happen in landfills.

Producing paper bags requires cutting down millions of trees. Paper bag production also requires large amounts of water and pollutes the environment.

BYOB (Bring Your Own Bag)

If neither paper nor plastic bags are eco-friendly choices, what is a shopper to do? One option is to use biodegradable plastic bags. However, it is not clear that these bags are much better for the environment than regular plastic bags.

The production of some biodegradable bags still requires petroleum products.

And due to a more complex manufacturing process, making biodegradable bags can result in even more greenhouse gas emissions than the production of regular plastic bags.

So what's left?

The Worldwatch Institute is an independent environmental research organization. According to its Web site, "the best alternative [to plastic bags] is to carry and reuse your own durable cloth bags."

Inexpensive, reusable bags are available at many stores. You can even buy reusable bags that fold up to the size of a wallet—easy for stashing in a purse or backpack, or even in a back pocket.


Read today’s story and answer the following question.

blog it Do you think plastic bag bans or fees are a good idea? Would you support one in your town?

Tell us what you think on the Scholastic News Online Blog!


Results of the 2009 Kids Environmental Report Card are due out this week! Stay tuned to Scholastic News Online for the details.


Get the latest on national and international events, movies, television, music, sports, and more from Scholastic News Online.

  • Teacher Store
  • The Teacher Store  
    NonFiction Library Grade 5

    NonFiction Library Grade 5

    This collection of quality nonfiction Scholastic titles was hand selected to provide you with the best books at the best prices.

    See below for complete list of titles. Appropriate titles of equal value may be substituted if any of the listed titles are unavailable at shipping time.

    Title list:
    • Achoo!
    • Albert Einstein
    • And Then What Happened, Paul Revere?
    • Bad News for Outlaws
    • Bill and Melinda Gates
    • Bones
    • Bully for You, Teddy Roosevelt!
    • Burp!
    • The Buzz on Bees
    • The Circulatory Story
    • Coming to America
    • Detector Dogs
    • Enemies of Slavery
    • Environmental Protection
    • Extreme Bridges
    • An Eye for Color
    • The Gettysburg Address
    • Got Geography!
    • Great Estimations
    • Growing Patterns
    • Guinness World Records: Bizarre Bug Records
    • Guinness World Records: Top Ten Amazing Pet Records
    • Ida B. Wells
    • If the World Were a Village
    • If You Lived at the Time of the Civil War
    • The Inuit
    • The Kid's Guide to Money
    • Louis Braille
    • Meteor Showers
    • The Moon
    • Nat Geo Kids—Everything: Everything Ancient Egypt
    • National Intelligence
    • Planets
    • Planting the Trees of Kenya
    • Rosa
    • The Secret Soldier
    • Serving on a Jury
    • Snakes
    • Soccermania / Futbolmanía
    • Stealing Home
    • Ten True Animal Rescues
    • Through My Eyes
    • Thunder on the Plains
    • A True Patriot
    • The Truth (and Myths) About the Presidents
    • Understanding Charts and Graphs
    • A Warmer World
    • Wetlands
    • Wild Tracks
    • You Want the Women to Vote, Lizzie Stanton?

    $206.10 You save: 38%
    Paperback Book Collection | Grade 5
    Add To Cart
    Educators Only
    NonFiction Library Grade 5
    Grade 5 $206.10
    Add To Cart
  • Teacher Store
  • The Teacher Store  
    Guided Reading Short Reads & Lecturas Cortas Bundle Grade 3 (Levels J-Q)

    Guided Reading Short Reads & Lecturas Cortas Bundle Grade 3 (Levels J-Q)

    Another great title from Scholastic. Detailed description coming soon.

    $1,346.00 You save: 36%
    Instructional Program | Grade 3
    Add To Cart
    Educators Only
    Guided Reading Short Reads & Lecturas Cortas Bundle Grade 3 (Levels J-Q)
    Grade 3 $1,346.00
    Add To Cart
Privacy Policy




Here's something interesting from