Source
Administrator Magazine
Scholastic Administrator is a must-read resource for 240,000 of today's results-driven school leaders. Every issue features leadership for education executives, insight and analysis into what's next in education, and reporting on cutting-edge technologies in real life applications.

This Month's Weigh In

Does weighted student funding work? Five administrators offer their views.

March/April 2009

A weighted student formula allows the money to follow the students and their needs,” says Dr. Arlene Ackerman, superintendent of the School District of Philadelphia. “I think that’s important. We know that poverty brings certain challenges. We have to address those, often before we can educate children. I wouldn’t want to think that because a poor child attends school on one side of town, and a similar student attends school on the other, they wouldn’t get the same resources. “But instructional strategies have to follow. Teacher effectiveness makes a huge difference. Putting in a weighted student formula without an academic plan will not help you reach the overarching goal of increasing student achievement.”

It could help our schools to reduce class size,” says Jill Wynns, school board member, San Francisco Unified School District. “We want to empower schools to make better decisions because they know what they need.... A lot of [elementary] schools have used weighted student funding to reduce class size. We have a state-funded reduced class size [program] for K–3 and federally funded reduced class size programs for middle and high schools, but the elementary schools were saying ‘we could afford one more teacher.’ If they have the money and the space.... We couldn’t know if we made that decision centrally.”

The model actually cost us more money,” says Linda Sebring, budget director for Seattle Public Schools. (Seattle used weighted student funding for years before switching in 2007 to weighted staffing funding.) “Approximately $7 million more, because [weighted student funding] masked the fact that there weren’t enough resources to provide services such as counseling and administrative support. Schools shifted all of their possible resources into class size reductions, eliminating some of the non-classroom staff. “One of the other issues we lost in the previous model was accountability. Who was responsible if a school didn’t perform? Not principals, since their building teams worked to identify the resource distribution at the school; not central administrators, since the school made resource decisions. It was a catch-22.”

We need to talk about it with parents and others who have a stake in public education,” says Philadelphia Federation of Teachers president Jerry Jordan. “Unless it’s clearly understood as benefiting schools and children, it just won’t be successful. “One thing I think parents and schools are concerned about is whether they perceive funding is being taken away from their community. “The work that goes into educating the public will be critically important. And it’s a matter of informing not only the parents but the employees in the schools. This is a completely new way of budgeting. “I would encourage a pilot [program] before expanding it to all schools.”

We tried it, but now use a uniform per-student formula,” says Deborah A. Gist, state superintendent for D.C. schools. “The uniform per-student funding formula is very similar. There’s a foundation amount and various weights assigned based on need. The difference is that uniform funding provides charter schools a funding system. “I think [weighted student funding] is a valuable tool for districts to ensure resources are equitably distributed ... as is any funding formula that is weighted to specific needs of the learner.”

  • Teacher Store
  • The Teacher Store  
    All About ADHD

    All About ADHD

    by Linda Jo Pfiffner

    Completely revised and updated version of All About ADHD. Will include latest research, research-based strategies, photographs, and more.

    Topics include:
    • ADHD-friendly classrooms
    • Behavior management basics
    • Individualized behavior programs
    • School-home connection
    • Evaluation programs

    $16.49 You save: 25%
    Professional Book | Grades K-8
    Add To Cart
    Educators Only
    All About ADHD
    Grades K-8 $16.49
    Add To Cart
  • Teacher Store
  • The Teacher Store  
    The Scholastic Differentiated Instruction Plan Book

    The Scholastic Differentiated Instruction Plan Book

    by Cindy Middendorf

    This 40-week planner is chockfull of resources to help teachers streamline and focus differentiated instruction. Designed by an award-winning teacher whose specialty is differentiation, this essential planner includes:
    • a large planning grid with mini-planning checklists for each week
    • a differentiation planning guide and lesson plan template
    • quick-tip guides and checklists for:
    • starting the year off right
    • selecting differentiated learning tools
    • tiering instruction
    • working with multiple intelligences and learning modalities
    • tapping higher-level thinking with Bloom's Taxonomy
    • using questioning strategies
    • integrating assessment
    • at-a-glance calendars and student information pages
    • weekly tips for differentiating instruction, management, and assessment
    PLUS: Writable, customize-and-print planning grids, lesson templates, and other tools to streamline planning and save time!

    $11.99 You save: 25%
    Planner Record Book | Grades 1-6
    Add To Cart
    Educators Only
    The Scholastic Differentiated Instruction Plan Book
    Grades 1-6 $11.99
    Add To Cart
Help | Privacy Policy
EMAIL THIS

* YOUR NAME

* YOUR EMAIL ADDRESS

* RECIPIENT'S EMAIL ADDRESS(ES)

(Separate multiple email addresses with commas)

Check this box to send yourself a copy of the email.

INCLUDE A PERSONAL MESSAGE (Optional)


Scholastic respects your privacy. We do not retain or distribute lists of email addresses.